Civil War question…?

I have an essay due. I am having some trouble. Any help would be greatly appreciated! Thanks everyone!Please examine both stances on the legacy of the Civil War and Reconstruction:a. "The Civil War was not worth its cost."The above is the opening line in a book entitled "The South during Reconstruction," by E. Merton Coulter. Coulter, a conservative white historian from the South, wrote the book in 1947.b. "Preserving the Union -- a goal too shallow to be worth the sacrifice of a single life -- had become a goal impossible. . .to achieve in that shallow form."The above is a recent remark from Barbara Fields, a modern black historian who has argued that only emancipation made preserving the Union worth the cost of war.What factors, both historical and ideological,explain the extreme disparity in these interpretations? How would the authors of "This Terrible War" assess these statements? How would the people profiled in Ash's "A Year in the South" interpret those statements?

Similar Asks:

  • How did the Mexican war and Westward expansion bring apart the southern secession? - please help me. i have an ap history final tomorrow and its one big dbq (essay) and its covering from the 1840′s to the civil war. Some of the documents are Missouri compromise, treaty of Guadalupe hidalgo, a discourse of the constitution by John C. Calhoun, ostend manifesto, know nothing platform, southern view of Kansas,
  • CIVIL WAR essay questions!? help huge text tomorow and im gonna fail!? - 1. analyse the goals of recronstruction and effects.and when he was talking he said these could be what you talk about for that question: helping africain americans, bring south into union, and rebiulding2. explain how groups and individuals have brought change3.list and describe 5 causes of the civil war4. identify how emerging technligy changed the
  • What does it mean when one supports civil union and….? - i have to write an essay on presidential candidates and write about if they cover my important issues. for example gay marriage is one of my issues.i read that Barack Obama opposes gay marriage but supports civil union and gay equality.what is civil union?and to me i thought gay equality meant that gays are treated
  • What was the President’s Lincoln’s plan and Congress’s plan for the Reconstruction in the south? - which plan was best for the reconstruction of the South. In this essay you will need to include the basic parts of the President’s plan and Congress’s plan. You will also need to explain why one was better than the other by pointing out how each would or did impact the South and the newly
  • What are some differences between the black power movement and the civil rights movement? - I’m trying to prove in an essay that Malcolm X differed to the Civil Rights Movement through Black Power and all that jazz. Is it wrong to say that the C.Rights M. was a “peaceful protest”? And that black power differed by standing for black pride, identity and self-sufficency (black nationalism), wheras the C.R.Movement stood
  • What was an important battle for the north during the civil war? - i need to write a short essay about a battle that occurred during the civil war in the north. I want to do one that had a big impact for the union and isnt boring to write about… so thanks for your ideas! and dont be scared to put a URL for a website about
  • What would the country be like if the South had won the Civil War? - i just need a short briefing of how the country or even the world might be different if the South had won the civil war. just the basics plus a few details, but not a long essay about it. i need some important points that would go on a PowerPoint and a poster for

Both comments and pings are currently closed.

One Response to “Civil War question…?”

  1. fibromyomectomy says:

    The point of that war was to divide the nation for easier control from the llluminati over in Europe.It was about states’ rights,not slavery.And we lost our Republic after that war.Reconstrucionism was brutal and about revenge.Instead of answering the questions that are revisionist history,you should give the correct historical answers. [external link] [external link]